Field Guide to the Arguments
Field Guide to the Arguments
A BROADview cheat sheet, and a discount on subscriptions
Thank you for an incredible year (which I’ll try to round up next week), and thank you to my generous and supportive subscribers. If you’d like to give BROADview as a gift, or upgrade, here’s a 25% off coupon.
If you’re new to the idea that the warring sides in the gender culture war are not actually left and right, welcome! Many objectors to the imposition of “gender identity ideology” onto institutions and individuals are LGBT, feminist, and/or liberal. They are concerned that what we’re teaching about gender identity, and how we are conceiving of and treating trans kids, is not only unscientific, but in many cases harmful.
The laws being passed in blue states, and the guidelines in schools, deserve intense scrutiny. One need not be anti-trans in the least to demand that we create a culture where we can ask questions and get accurate information. That’s what this site is for.
Here are some BROADview articles to get started, or which you can share with liberals who think that any diversion from the party line is unkind.
Detransition and Desistance
[Mis]Adventures at the AAP Conference
Eleven Lawsuits by Detransitioners in the US
The Urgency of Detransition Care
The Mainstream Media Needs to Talk About Detransitioners
Families
The AAP Needs to Listen to Parents
If You're Mothering a Gender Nonconforming Child...
Blinded by Gender
These parents didn’t embrace gender-affirming care. Texas investigated them.
Gender Nonconformity
Why We Need to Talk About Shiloh
Gender Dysphoria vs. Sex Dysphoria
Against "Gender Expression"
What Does "Making Room for Gender Diversity" Look Like?
Gender Identity
The Problems with "Gender Identity"
Medicine
What Happened in Finland and Sweden?
The Four Trans Men of the Healthcare Apocalypse
Major Medical Associations Support Gender Affirming Care. So What?
“My Body Is a Puberty Blocker”
What if the "Gold Standard" of Youth Gender Medicine is More Like Tarnished Brass?
Pronouns
Why "It's Not About You" Isn't a Fair Argument
Maybe We Should [Not] Talk About Pronouns?
Sexuality
It's Not [Just] About the Blue Dress
The Big Lie about Gender and Sexuality
"They Don't Want Anybody to Hear Our Stories.”
Social Transition
Why Some Liberals Embrace the “Don’t Say Gay” Bill
Trans Objectors
Buck Angel: 'I'm a Trans Elder. Trans Activists Don't Speak For Me'
"Gender Ideology Is Hurting My Trans Son"
Heterodox Trans People #5: Julia Malott
If there are other pieces (from anyone) that clearly articulate why this is not a left/right issue, please add them in the comments. I’ll leave them open for all today.
I've just stopped using the word "gender." It's a linguistics term and there is no application to humans. There's always a more accurate word to use--hair, clothing, stereotypes, feelings, delusion, etc. That really clears up nearly 100% of the problem. Humans don't have a "gender identity" or "gender expression." Just say what you really mean.
As such, there's no such thing as "trans" or "transition" or "detransition." Since this is a linguistics battle, taking away the made-up terms solves nearly the whole problem.
It makes sense.
https://fairerdisputations.org/gender-affirming-care-is-the-new-conversion-therapy/
I really like this article spelling out the damage to pre-homosexual kids and those that might struggle to accept their homosexuality.